No competitor was allowed publish any problem until after the publication of the annual report.
No annual report has been found. No local committe publication has been found.
In the correspondence section of Illustrated London News for 1858-10-02 two other competitors are mentioned:
[...]; next in excellence to [F. Healey's] compositions the examiners have marked the problems submitted by G. M. and R. B. Wormald, [...]suggesting that a report was finished at some point.
Prize: F. Healey
Key: 1. Rg4+
Source: Illustrated London News, v. 33, i. 947 (1858-11-27), p. 512, prb. 771
Key: 1. Qf4
Source: Illustrated London News, v. 33, i. 939 (1858-10-02), p. 317, prb. 763