Croydon Guardian, 1884 (Endgame tourney)
1 pr. | A. F. Mackenzie (Motto: Softly, softly, ketch monkey.) |
2 pr. | J. Jespersen (Mandefold)) |
3 pr. | E. Marks (Hæ tibi sunt artes, no. 1) |
hm. | L. P. Rees |
O. Meisling |
The formal announcement was preceded by several attempts to decide the
likelihood that sufficient number of entries would be forthcoming (Croydon
Guardian, 1883-09-08, 1883-09-22, 1883-10-06).
While no motto requirement had been expressed, mottos appear to have been provided by all competitors.
Twenty-two endgames in nineteen entries were examined, though only 21
appear to have been published. Eleven were faulty, of
which six were absolutely wrong,
two doubtful if they fulfilled conditions, and
three having second solutions. The judge reported on the perceived
issues in some detail in the report.
A possible additional issue with the soundness of some of the awarded positions appear
to have been found during the
six-week grace period before the awards were declared final, but eventually they were confirmed as final. (The
confirmation notice refers to "Mr. W. N. Potter's award" for unknown reasons.)
A solution tourney for tourney endgames was also announced. It was
reported together with the main competition, as C. E. Ranken was
the judge for both. The solution tourney received solutions from
only one solver from Denmark who wished to remain anonymous, and it appears
to have been closed without any awards.
The HHdbVI endgame database notes that the 3 pr. winner is cooked (multiple
solutions?).
Prizes
1st Prize: A. F. Mackenzie
+
2nd Prize: J. Jespersen
=